Jewish! Studying and living the Torah.

The Thirteen Principles of Faith of Maimonides – Part II: Darwin’s Theory of Evolution Weakens Faith in G-d

For 14 days, we read in the synagogue about the creation of the world and the earliest history of humanity. Faith was shaken. In recent centuries, faith has once again come under pressure. The criticism has not gone away. We stand by our faith. How should we deal with this criticism? I would like to present a few ideas.

Maimonides’ sixth and seventh principles of faith state:

  1. I believe with perfect faith that all the words of the prophets are true.
  2. I believe with firm faith that the prophecy of our teacher Moses is true and that he is the father of the prophets who preceded him and those who came after him.

The Misuse of Darwinism

At the beginning of the Torah, Moses describes how the world was created in seven days, including the rest of Shabbat. In this context, the theory of evolution poses a major problem. In principle, the theory of evolution does not have to deny the existence of G-d or His governance of the world. Nevertheless, Darwinism has often been, and continues to be, invoked as a way of escaping the authority of religion.

Since Darwin, Faith Has Been Put to the Test

For most believers, their relationship with G-d does not depend on a proof of G-d’s existence, because they have already come to faith by other means. An atheist generally cannot be convinced by proofs of G-d’s existence. An agnostic assumes that human reasoning is incapable of conclusively proving that G-d exists. An infinite, unknowable G-d cannot truly be comprehended.

The Theory of Evolution Is Diametrically Opposed to the Theory of Creation

So who created this world? Should we return to Greek thought, which assumed that matter had simply existed eternally? This is nothing more than playing with words. Moreover, the intellect is not a reliable compass when it comes to this question. G-d does not make things easy for us. He does so in order to leave us free to choose. The result is a search with no predetermined outcome. There are counterarguments to everything. What are the alternatives? Throughout our entire development as human beings, we have been searching.

Did Everything Emerge from Chaos?

Order has never emerged from chaos unless an external guiding hand was involved. Can an overturned inkwell write a poem? Scientists, in particular, should marvel at the complexity, systematic structure, regularity, and interconnectedness of nature. Intelligent Design in nature astonishes everyone. This cannot be mere coincidence.

Why Do So Many People Accept Darwin’s Theory Blindly?

Darwin pushes the account of Genesis back by several billion years. But he does not resolve the question of the origin of time, space, and matter either. Darwin’s advantage is that his theory offers a clear and comprehensible picture. A gradual process from single-celled organisms to animals and human beings is easy for the average mind to understand and visualize. Moreover, it is entirely value-neutral. Human beings do not have to do anything in particular. They can do whatever they feel like doing.

Then the sense of meaninglessness sets in. What is the purpose of everything? What drives the fittest—or the best—to survive? Darwin’s appeal lies in the absence of values and norms. The meaning and significance of life begin to fade.

If we are descended from single-celled organisms, every religious obligation loses its force. But if we were created by a G-d who establishes moral norms, we must observe all kinds of exalted commandments.

Are We Descended from Animals?

For those who study animal psychology, the transition from ape to human being is scientifically very unlikely. The gap between humans and animals is enormous, especially in the intellectual realm. No animal has ever been observed navigating with a map or making fire. Can animals think logically? This does not appear to have been proven. The opposite seems more plausible.

Do the Animal Mind and the Human Psyche Gradually Merge?

There is an unbridgeable gap between human and animal thought. The academic journal Behavioral and Brain Sciences states unequivocally that humanity has “bridged a great cognitive gap” (more than a quantum jump: a genuine quality jump). Animals lack self-reflection. Moreover, it is unfair to measure animal intelligence using the human IQ scale. Perhaps animals operate on a completely different mental wavelength. Can animals reason using syllogisms? If A is greater than B, and B is greater than C, must A therefore be greater than C? No. Even chimpanzees do not grasp cause-and-effect relationships.

What About the Survival of the Fittest?

The concept of “survival of the fittest” sounds appealing, but it already runs into difficulties when applied to human beings. As the final stage of the evolutionary ladder and supposedly the “fittest” species, we are struck by the complete helplessness of human infants. Human beings should be able to walk and speak immediately. Instead, they remain dependent on others for a very long time. So far advanced in evolution, yet so helpless! The counterargument, however, is that this very fact points to the advanced development of human beings, according to some.

The World Was Created “Complete”

Look at the universe. The most distant stars are seven billion light-years away from us. Can we conclude from this that the universe is therefore “at least seven billion years old”? No. For when the world was created, it was already fully “complete.” The universe was created with all its celestial bodies. Suddenly, there was an Earth with flora, fauna, seas, and mountains, including trees that already had a certain age.

Adam Counts the Tree Rings

Suppose Adam had cut down a tree in Paradise and counted 500 tree rings. Would that mean that the tree—and the world itself—was 500 years old? No! The Almighty had created both seeds and fully grown trees. G-d created the world “complete,” with ores and carbon already in the ground. G-d created not only the stars but also their light, as though these celestial bodies had been revolving in space for millions of years.

Was There a Gap in Time?

Perhaps the concept of time was different on the first day. The sun and moon did not yet exist. Yet the text says: “And there was evening and there was morning, the first day.” Did the speed of light, which determines the speed of time, change after the Flood? Who can say?

Mammoths in Siberia

Then mammoths were discovered in Siberia. Rabbi J. Lipschutz, the renowned commentator of Tiferet Yisrael, lived shortly before Darwin and quotes the Talmud (B.T. Chagigah 16a), which states that G-d created and destroyed many worlds. The Torah says nothing about the length of time between “In the beginning, G-d created the heavens and the earth” and “The earth was formless and empty.” Did these two moments follow one another immediately? Not necessarily. Perhaps many worlds were created in between.

Since all kinds of prehistoric fossils were being discovered during his lifetime, Rabbi Lipschutz concluded that these excavations actually confirmed the Talmudic teachings. More than 1,500 years before prehistoric skeletons were discovered, Jewish scholars were already discussing this subject. They had identified the remains of older worlds upon which our world had arisen.

In Any Case, G-d Created Darwin

After developing his theory, Darwin thanked G-d on his knees. There is no film of the Creation on YouTube. The Talmud says it all: Do not investigate everything that came before Creation; you would not be able to understand it anyway.

Cookies Notice

Our website uses cookies. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with this.